NEW ORLEANS, La. —
Transocean employees should have done more to detect signs of trouble before the company’s drilling rig exploded in the Gulf of Mexico in 2010, killing 11 workers and triggering the nation’s worst offshore oil spill, the company’s chief executive testified Tuesday.
However, the Swiss-based drilling company’s own investigation of the disaster didn’t find any mistakes beyond the rig floor, Transocean Ltd. president and CEO Steven Newman said. He testified on the 14th day of a trial designed to determine the causes of BP’s well blowout and to assign fault to the companies involved.
Newman said Transocean didn’t identify any “management failures” that led to the blowout.
“I think we had a good system in place,” he said.
Newman testified that Transocean agreed in January to plead guilty to a criminal charge of violating the Clean Water Act because its rig workers on the Deepwater Horizon played a role in botching a crucial safety test before the blowout.
“Do you blame the crew that night?” Transocean attorney Brad Brian asked Newman.
“Do I blame the crew? Do I wish the crew would have done more? Absolutely. I am not sure that that’s the same emotional content as blame,” Newman said.
Newman, however, said BP ultimately was responsible for deciding how to perform the safety test and for determining whether it was successful.
Two BP rig supervisors, Robert Kaluza and Donald Vidrine, are charged with manslaughter in the 11 rig workers’ deaths and await a separate trial. An indictment last year accused Kaluza and Vidrine of disregarding abnormally high pressure readings during the safety test.
No Transocean employees have been charged with crimes, but the company pleaded guilty to the misdemeanor charge in February and agreed to pay $1.4 billion in criminal and civil penalties as part of a settlement with the Justice Department.
BP’s internal investigation of the blowout also spared its own upper-level managers from any blame. Instead, the London-based oil giant issued a report that outlined a series of mistakes by rig workers and faulted decisions by other companies.
Newman touted the company’s safety culture, saying any rig worker is empowered to call a halt to a drilling operation. If a worker sees any cause for concern, he said, “You not only have the right but the obligation to call a timeout.”
“Safety is one of our core values,” Newman said. “I think it is fundamental to what we do. “
He also praised the Deepwater Horizon for its “exemplary track record” before the Macondo blowout and for doing “some pretty amazing things,” including drilling a different BP-owned well in the Gulf to a record depth of 35,050 feet in 2009.
“The Deepwater Horizon was one our best performing rigs,” he said.
Elsewhere, 2009 was a rough year for Transocean. Newman said the company temporarily suspended operations on its entire fleet of rigs after four workers were killed in separate incidents within a 92-day period that year.
“I don’t think there’s any other conclusion you can draw than we had a problem,” Newman said during cross-examination by plaintiffs’ attorney Robert Cunningham.
The deaths, coupled with an increasing number of “high-potential incidents,” prompted Newman to order an independent review of the company’s safety management system.
“I think sometimes the difference between a high-potential incident and an actual injury is nothing more than luck,” Newman said, citing an example of rig equipment that falls harmlessly to the deck instead of hitting somebody.
“Are you telling us that control of high-potential incidents such as what occurred on the Deepwater Horizon is a matter of luck?” Cunningham asked. “Is that Transocean’s safety philosophy?”
“Absolutely not,” Newman responded. “Our objective is to prevent all incidents.”
Newman closed out his testimony by saying he thinks every day about the 11 men who died.
“Why?” Brian asked him.
After a long pause, Newman cleared his throat and answered, “Because I ask myself if there isn’t something more I could have done.”
U.S. District Judge Carl Barbier is hearing testimony without a jury and, barring a settlement, could decide how much more money BP and its contractors should pay for their roles in the catastrophe.
Barbier also heard testimony Tuesday from Tim Quirk, who was a laboratory manager for Halliburton, BP’s cement contractor on the Deepwater Horizon.
Shortly after the blowout, Quirk performed tests on a cement slurry with the same composition of what was used at the Macondo well. But he said another Halliburton employee instructed him not to submit a written report on the test results and only share them verbally.
“It was a little unusual,” he said of the instruction.
Quirk said he complied and threw away his notes.
“Looking way back at it now, I can understand the importance of it. But back then I just didn’t see it that way,” he said, noting that he had used “off-the-shelf” lab ingredients for the test.
Last week, Halliburton attorney Donald Godwin told Barbier that the company only recently discovered cement samples that weren’t turned over to the Justice Department after the spill.
Godwin said Halliburton believes the material found last Wednesday at its laboratory in Lafayette has no bearing on the trial, but plaintiffs’ attorney Jeffrey Breit said the samples are cement a Halliburton employee used for testing of the Macondo well.
Quirk said he secured all of the samples he believed were related to the Macondo well in a locker and put everything else in a warehouse, never suspecting the recently discovered samples could be related to the case.
“I had no way of knowing,” he said.
State News
Transocean CEO: Rig workers should have done more
- State News
-
-
Fire chief says search almost complete in Oklahoma
The search for survivors and the dead is nearly complete in the Oklahoma City suburb that was smashed by a mammoth tornado, the fire chief said Tuesday.
-
Indian guest workers sue company in Miss., Texas
Dozens of Indian guest workers are suing an Alabama-based marine and fabrication company, claiming it financially exploited them and forced them to live in squalid conditions after bringing them to work at Gulf Coast shipyards after Hurricane Katrina.
-
Man wants pay for snakes seized in Miss. porn case
A man serving 30 years after pleading guilty to enticing a teenager to pose for pornographic pictures with venomous snakes has filed a federal lawsuit seeking compensation for the loss of his reptiles.
-
Tornado churns through Oklahoma City suburbs
A mile-wide tornado churned through the Oklahoma City suburbs, destroying homes for the second day in a row Monday, as part of a severe weather outbreak that was expected to spread in other parts of the Plains and Midwest.
-
Tchnology can speed emergency response
Recent national tragedies have reminded us once again how important it is to stay in touch with loved ones and emergency response officials for breaking news. Being technology-ready before disaster strikes is critical to saving lives, connecting friends and family, and assisting first responders.
I -
Miss. seniors get another shot to pass grad tests
Mississippi officials are trying to retest hundreds of high school seniors who flunked exams that are required for graduation.
-
Only abortion clinic in Miss. fights to stay open
It can’t meet the mandates of a 2012 state law and the governor wants to shut it down, but Mississippi’s only abortion clinic is not about to quietly retreat.
-
Ex-BP engineer claims feds withheld evidence
A former BP engineer charged with deleting text messages about the company’s response to its 2010 oil spill in the Gulf of Mexico urged a federal judge Tuesday to sanction Justice Department prosecutors for allegedly withholding evidence in the case, a claim the prosecutors deny.
-
Amtrak unveils locomotives to replace aging fleet
When Amtrak unveiled the first of 70 new locomotives Monday at a plant in California, it marked what the national passenger railroad service hopes will be a new era of better reliability, streamlined maintenance and better energy efficiency.
-
Miss. health agency to resume pregnancy work
Mississippi Medicaid officials will resume paying state Health Department workers to help women with high-risk pregnancies.
- More State News Headlines
-
Fire chief says search almost complete in Oklahoma




