Appeals court to review Miss. death row inmate’s re-sentencing

Local News

April 25, 2007

Anonymous Picayune Item Wed Apr 25, 2007, 10:39 AM CDT

Jackson — A federal appeals court will decide whether a Mississippi death row inmate’s rights were violated when, at his re-sentencing, he was not allowed to rebut prosecutors’ claim that he killed a teenager while committing rape.

The 5th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, in an order issued Monday, said death row inmate Gerald James Holland raised a possible constitutional question on what evidence a defendant can present when facing a new sentencing hearing for a capital crime.

Mississippi prosecutors had argued to the 5th Circuit that, under state law, once guilt is established in a separate trial those, issues cannot be re-debated during the sentencing phase.

In Mississippi, capital murder cases require two jury trials — one on guilt or innocence, and a second to determine a life sentence or death. Death penalty appeals go directly to the state Supreme Court.

Also, capital murder is defined in Mississippi as murder committed with another felony — in Holland’s case, rape.

Holland argued to the 5th Circuit that this was an re-sentencing with a new jury that did not deal with issues of guilt and innocence.

Holland said prosecutors put on evidence that he raped and killed 15-year-old Krystal King in the 1980s, but that he was not allowed to put on evidence to the contrary.

Prosecutors said Holland should not be allowed to re-litigate the issue of his guilt at his re-sentencing.

The 5th Circuit said it was that dual function that raises a constitutional question in Holland’s case.

“The lack of rebuttal evidence makes it much more likely that a jury would find that the state met its burden with respect to that aggravating circumstance. We believe reasonable jurists would find the resolution of this argument debatable,” the 5th Circuit said.

Holland was convicted of capital murder and sentenced to death in 1987 in the slaying of King. Prosecutors said King was raped, beaten and stabbed. The cause of death was asphyxiation caused by choking, according to the court record.

The Mississippi Supreme Court in 1991 upheld Holland’s conviction but threw out the death sentence.

Holland was re-sentenced to death in 1993 by a Harrison County jury. The Mississippi high court upheld the second death sentence in 1997. The Mississippi court rejected Holland’s claim that he should be allowed to counter the rape evidence, called an aggravating circumstance considered by the jury in imposing punishment.

U.S. District Judge William H. Barbour Jr. sided with the state court in 2006. Holland appealed to the 5th Circuit.

Monday’s ruling was issued by a panel of three 5th Circuit judges — Harold R. DeMoss Jr., Carl E. Stewart and Edward Charles Prado.

Text Only

Local News

Bar fight ends in man being run over
A bar fight Friday morning resulted in one man being run over by the other with a pickup truck.
The fight was reported to Picayune Police officers Friday morning at about 1:44 at the American Legion Hall on Union School Road, said Capt. Chad Dorn.

February 4, 2012
Arson suspected at possible murder site
Pearl River County Sheriff’s Department investigators suspect arson was involved in a structure fire that occurred at a home where James Raine was killed last year.
The home at 24 Emma Lane was the scene of what investigators believe was the murder of the 37-year-old Raine in October, 2011.

February 4, 2012 1 Photo
Inmate escapes leaving father’s wake
Johnny Hall Jr., 30, escaped from Mississippi Department of Corrections custody Friday afternoon while attending his father’s wake in Picayune.

February 4, 2012
Inmate escapes from funeral procession
State inmate Johnny Hall, Jr., escaped from two Wilkinson County Correctional Facility officers’ custody today at approximately 12:30 p.m. while being escorted from his father’s wake at the Picayune Funeral Home in Picayune, Miss.

February 3, 2012
REPAIRING GAS LEAK
Contract and city workers were at this gas leak on Beech Street installing a clamp.

February 3, 2012 1 Photo
CAMELLIA SHOW
The Poplarville Garden Club Community Camellia Show is today in the lobby of the Poplarville branch of Hancock Bank.

February 3, 2012 1 Photo
Local gas prices continue a gradual upward trend
From Monday to Thursday, the per gallon price of regular gasoline at RaceTrac jumped six cents, from $3.289 to $3.349. RaceTrac sets the pace in Pearl River County for the lowest posted price, and Wal-Mart and Bill’s Quick Stop at Mississippi Highway 43 and East Canal quickly follow.

February 3, 2012 1 Photo
StennisSphere closing
StennisSphere is closing it’s doors to make way for a new tourist attraction, and to help increase security at John C. Stennis Space Center. According to a press release from Stennis, the tourist attraction officially will close in mid February.

February 3, 2012
ENJOYING THE RAIN
These ducks weren’t phased by Wednesday’s rainy conditions.

February 2, 2012 1 Photo
Picayune featured in “Blondie” comic strip
Occupy Picayune?
All Mr. Dithers wants to see occupied is Dagwood’s desk chair.
That is part of the adventures of Dagwood Bumstead, which includes a mention of the City of Picayune in Friday’s “Blondie” comic strip, which appears in the Picayune Item as a daily feature.
Picayune’s mention in Friday’s strip that also is released in other publications gives Picayune a name recognition boost worldwide, says the artist who draws the feature, Frank Cummings, a former Picayune resident and former employee of the Picayune Item.

February 2, 2012 1 Photo
More Local News Headlines

Local News

Search Results

Appeals court to review Miss. death row inmate’s re-sentencing

Site Map

Contact Us