Is liquor really our economic salvation?

Letters

September 30, 2009

Anonymous Picayune Item Wed Sep 30, 2009, 11:08 AM CDT

Editor:

The Picayune Item has come out strongly in favor of bringing liquor sales to Pearl River County. I feel that the other side of the issue should be given equal airing.

Some people who move here are surprised to learn that this is a dry county – except for beer in Picayune. In this day and age that is a bit unusual, but it is one of the factors in our local culture that makes this a special place to live. Many of us think there is a value to that culture that should not be discarded lightly, because once we change it we can never go back. This isn’t a minor thing; it would forever change the unique culture of Pearl River County as we know it.

The argument that we should “be like everybody else” is a weak one. I’m reminded of the old parental retort, “If your friends jumped off a cliff would you follow them?”

People who feel the need to be close to a source of liquor have plenty of other places where they could choose to live. People who prefer not to live in that environment ought to have a place of choice as well, and that place is here.

There is a misconception that the law would merely allow people to have a cocktail or glass of wine with a meal. In fact, it would allow restaurants to have a full-fledged bar, as long as they also have a substantial amount of revenue from food sales. Bar patrons could drink all they want without buying food.

We’re talking about establishing bars, period. Liquor advocates are well aware that this is the first and most difficult step. After that, the rest of the dominoes fall easily. It wouldn’t be long before someone would complain that it’s not fair for only restaurants to have bars and not independent operators. Then comes the idea that it’s unfair to have to buy liquor by the drink instead of in bottles. Then county residents should have the same rights as city residents. Drip, drip, drip.

The big argument offered for legalizing liquor is that it would attract new businesses and bring economic growth. This is the saddest excuse of all. All you have to do is whisper “economic growth” in the ears of some politicians and they will embrace anything. But think about it. Do you really think liquor is the answer to Pearl River County’s future? Of all the ways we could create jobs, this is the best we can come up with? We could list many other vices that might bring in more dollars but I doubt we want to legalize such things, despite the old saw that people are going to do it anyway.

Will liquor make this a better place? Has more liquor ever made anything better?

By the way, liquor won’t stop people from shopping in Slidell. It’s a bigger town; it has more stores.

This bizarre state law that allows any place in Mississippi to be designated a “resort area” so they can serve liquor, through a rather convoluted backdoor legislative maneuver, is kind of disturbing. Well, it’s kind of dishonest, really. If we’re a resort, where are the cabanas and tourist traps?

Comes now the Applebees angle, the “big revelation” that an Applebees “might” have been interested in coming here. This is cited as the ultimate proof that we have to legalize liquor. Oh, please. Does anyone have any hard numbers, actual verifiable data that could show the economic benefits of liquor? They don’t because there are no such numbers. Liquor isn’t the pivotal issue for very many businesses considering a move here. It’s about the market.

Some people just want liquor here for their personal convenience. The economic argument is a convenient hook and may sway a lot of people, but it has little substance.

Our local law enforcement agencies are keeping quiet about this, maybe because they want to stay out of the politics of it. But I doubt that they’re thrilled at the prospect of more drunk drivers and domestic tragedies, as is sure to happen. Prove it, you say? Okay, does anyone think liquor would mean fewer drunk drivers? You may have heard the argument that it would be better for people to drive drunk a shorter distance than all the way from Slidell, but somehow that isn’t too comforting. It seems to me the shorter drive would be more of a temptation to drive drunk. Has anyone checked with the auto insurers to see where rates would go when our drunk driver accidents increase?

To sum it up:

1. Legalizing liquor would mean a profound and irreversible change in the culture of Pearl River County. Let’s think long and hard about whether we want that.

2. If liquor is the Holy Grail of economic growth for our community, something is really, really wrong.

Dave Sims

Text Only

Letters

Why are telemarketers with a personal agenda exempt from the “No Call List”?
Why are telemarketers with a personal agenda exempt from the “No Call List”?
I’m on the Mississippi ‘no call list’.
My family and I sat down to dinner last night at 7 p.m. (Oct. 17). At 7:10 p.m., we received a telephone call from a fast-talking, pro-life ‘Christian’ group saying they were call 33,000 Mississippians at the same time and that we were all in a live “town hall meeting” and, if we stayed on the line, we could ask questions. Of course, it turned out to be a pre-recorded call. My dinner got cold while I tried to figure out who was calling and to discover a way to delete my number from their calling list.

October 25, 2011
Reader has problem with utility bills
Gentlemen:
Even if rental spaces are vacant, I still have to pay the City’s utility bill for each space. At that rate, my utilities are $4,800; whereas, taxes on my building are $4,500.

October 20, 2011
Shock and grief on 9-11
Editor:
I spent September 11, 2001, as much of the world did: on the Internet, sharing in the global outpouring of shock and grief. I will never forget the juxtaposition of the ruined skyscrapers against an appalling blue sky. Americans of all backgrounds queued to give blood, to donate, to enlist in an imminent war. Others sought ways to serve at home through national service.

September 10, 2011
Writer opposes Contraflow
Editor:
And to all officials that have to do with starting Contraflow traffic.
Do not, do not do Contraflow traffic. Let the people go on about their way, they know where they are going.

September 3, 2011
Anger over checkpoint
Editor:
Mississippi State Troopers had a roadblock/checkpoint set up at the intersection of Hwy 603 & Hwy 43 in Kiln on Saturday morning July 30. As my wife and I approached this check point we were not worried, as my Dodge Ram Pickup was in good running order with all proper documentation.

September 2, 2011
From a senior’s point of view:
Editor:
We the public (people) have been lied to and have no idea where our taxed monies have been spent. All could not have been spent on the wars.
First: the federal taxes paid in the years we worked; were to run the country. Or so I thought and with any luck some left over.

September 2, 2011
Why I am a member of the Democratic Party
In response to your article prior to the Primary Election about the demise of the Democratic Party in Pearl River County, I am a Democrat and proud to say so. Let me outline my reasons for being a member of this demonized party.

August 24, 2011
Open primary ballot needed
The election on this past Tuesday once again proved the need for an open primary ballot. One that has all of the names listed in alphabetical order for each office regardless of party affiliation, independent or otherwise. If this had been in place at this election it would have been less confusion and more realistic democratic results. The restraints fixed by party vote prevent the voter from exercising his choice for each candidate. Many voters would choose some Republicans and some Democrats and would not make a 100% exclusive party choice. The party ballot that we are now using prevents a voter from exercising his own individual choice as to candidates for each office.

August 16, 2011
Salter’s Medicaid “Time Bomb” is an Economic Boom for Mississippi
Editor:
For too long as a state, we’ve been baited by pundits and politicians alike into a false sense of self-sufficiency. While Mississippi is indeed a charitable state, we receive our share of charity as well. That’s why Sid Salters characterization last week of Medicaid as a “ticking time bomb” is both puzzling and disturbing to me. I don’t know about you, but the thought of a ticking time bomb brings nothing positive to my mind. The constant campaign of mistruths, half-truths and outright lies about Medicaid continues to further the theme that Medicaid is a curse and not the blessing that it really is to this state. Medicaid, without a doubt, is one of the surest job creators we have.

July 29, 2011
Local reader is part of that one percentile
Editor:
I am one of the 1%
Entitlement? What the hell is wrong here?
Remember, not only did you contribute to Social Security but your employer did too. It totaled 15% of your income before taxes. If you averaged only 30K over your working life, that’s close to $220,500. If you calculate the future value of $4,500 per year (yours & your employer’s contribution) at a simple 5% (less than what the govt. pays on the money that it borrows), after 49 years of working (me) you’d have $892,919.98. If you took out only 3% per year, you receive $26,787.60 per year and it would last better than 30 years, and that’s with no interest paid on that final amount on deposit! If you bought an annuity and it paid 4% per year, you’d have a lifetime income of $2,976.40 per month. The folks in Washington have pulled off a bigger Ponzi scheme than Bernie Madoff ever had.

July 28, 2011
More Letters Headlines

Letters

Search Results

Is liquor really our economic salvation?

Site Map

Contact Us