High court considers death penalty, intent

Editorials

December 11, 2012

High court considers death penalty, intent

AP Analysis

Associated Press Associated Press Tue Dec 11, 2012, 09:33 AM CST

JACKSON — Death row inmate Bobby Batiste has left the Mississippi Supreme Court in a quandary over intent.

In Mississippi, capital murder is defined as murder combined with another crime, called an underlying felony. In this case, it is robbery.

Yet, Batiste’s attorney told the court this past week that Batiste didn’t intend to steal a wallet hours after he beat his roommate to death.

Prosecutors said intent was an issue for the jury. Batiste’s attorney said had the jury be instructed about intent, Steiner said Batiste might have been convicted of murder or manslaughter and avoided a death sentence.

Presiding Justice Jess Dickinson summed it up for the Supreme Court: “This case has brought forward an issue we haven’t addressed before.”

Dickinson said jurors were presented a “good circumstantial evidence case,” in that Batiste was caught with the victim’s property and they can infer the intent.

“Doesn’t the jury have the right to decide that at the time of the murder that he had intent to rob?” Dickinson said.

Mississippi law lists a variety of underlying felonies and circumstances by which prosecutors can seek a death sentence — murder during a robbery is one along with rape, burglary, kidnapping, arson, sexual battery and others.

Mississippi law does not specifically address intent — the state of mind accompanying an act especially a forbidden act, according to Black’s Law Dictionary.

What the court decides could prompt lawmakers to take a look at a capital punishment law unchanged for 35 years.

Batiste, of Preston, was sentenced to death in 2009 in Oktibbeha County for killing his roommate, Andreas Galanis of Biloxi. Both were students at Mississippi State University. Prosecutors say Galanis died from a blow to the head after the two got into a fight at their off-campus apartment.

There were different explanations what occurred in the apartment. Batiste had claimed self-defense — that Galanis attacked him first. Batiste also said Galanis called him a bad name and Batiste struck out in the heat of passion.

Alison Steiner with the Office of Capital Defense Counsel said robbery was not the intent of Batiste. Steiner said prosecutors during Batiste’s trial said they didn’t have to prove intent and the trial judge wouldn’t let the defense raise it.

Batiste claimed prosecutors presented no evidence to when and how he came into possession of the victim’s wallet.

Steiner said Batiste told authorities he panicked after hitting his roommate and left to do some personal business, see his girlfriend and other friends. He later returned to the apartment, saw the blood and decided to clean up. In cleaning up, Steiner said Batiste got Galanis’ wallet along with other bloody items.

Steiner said the murder and the robbery were not linked in what the courts have called a “continuous chain of events.”

“This jury was told intent was irrelevant. Intent must be proven and the jury must not have the impression that intent was irrelevant,” Steiner said.

Assistant Attorney General Jason Davis told the court that the issue was there for the jury to decide. He said the jury was fully instructed on the elements of robbery.

“That’s what the jury is to determine,” Davis said. “That’s what they did. There was no error at all. We are being asked to go along with the series of events as Mr. Batiste said. We cannot accept anything Mr. Batiste said as true.”

The alleged break in the series of events — or “continuous chain of events” — is what appeared to concern Dickinson and some other justices.

Davis said the Supreme Court should uphold the jury’s verdict because, as he said, the jury weighed all the facts and “clearly supported that the robbery occurred.”

Text Only

Editorials

Bryant tantrum on education major standards was misguided
By the (McComb) Enterprise-Journal:
That was quite a tantrum Gov. Phil Bryant pitched at the College Board recently, criticizing its members for voicing concerns about his effort to increase standards for education majors.

March 29, 2013
Legislature to City Hall not sure move
Five Mississippi House members are running for mayor this year, and while name recognition might provide some advantage, lawmakers have had a mixed record in trying to go from the Capitol to City Hall.

March 27, 2013
Nation’s economy improving, but state’s still lagging
By The (Jackson) Clarion-Ledger
It’s been a long time coming, but finally there are bright economic signs nationally that seem here to stay a while.

March 23, 2013
Armed teachers dangerous idea for school safety
By (Columbus) The Commercial Dispatch:
The Mississippi House of Representatives sent back to the Senate a bill that would arm teachers.
Before sending it over, the House, by a 70-46 vote, amended the Senate’s bill in two major ways. Actually, the House did more than amend it. They neutered it.

March 22, 2013
Not every bill grabs headlines
The first two bills that Mississippi Gov. Phil Bryant signed during the 2013 legislative session dealt with money.
House Bill 19 gave more cash to the agency that coordinates a program to put all emergency offices under the same digital communications system. House Bill 20 moved money from the car tag reduction fund to the Budget Contingency Fund. Lawmakers use the contingency fund to cobble together cash for the overall state budget.

March 20, 2013
Transparency key to ‘best watchdogs’ oversight
By The (Tupelo) Northeast Mississippi Daily Journal:
Rep. Jerry Turner’s effort to require open meetings of water associations and notice of meetings in which members of boards of directors will be elected remains alive in the Legislature. It should be enacted in the interests of transparency in the running of the nonprofit associations providing water for a significant percentage of Mississippi’s population.

March 16, 2013
Miss. makes news, good news, this time
By The (Columbus) Commercial Dispatch:
Generally, when Mississippi makes national news — especially of late — it is not the sort of notoriety we welcome. ...
So March 3, when Mississippi again made national news, we braced ourselves for the embarrassment that was sure to follow.
Only this time, it wasn’t anything to be embarrassed about.
Imagine that.

March 15, 2013
Ag’s legal expenses top $2.4M for year
An ongoing lawsuit challenging Mississippi’s foster care system has cost the state at least $4.4 million in legal expenses and fees since 2008.
Expenses continue to rise as the plaintiffs and the state work toward a telephone status conference scheduled for April 25 with U.S. District Judge Tom S. Lee. The price tag this year is $1.35 million.

March 13, 2013
Ag’s legal expenses top $2.4M for year
An ongoing lawsuit challenging Mississippi’s foster care system has cost the state at least $4.4 million in legal expenses and fees since 2008.

March 13, 2013
Higher pay best way to recruit better teachers
By The (McComb) Enterprise-Journal:
A centerpiece of Gov. Phil Bryant’s proposals to improve education in Mississippi is raising the requirements for college students to major in the education field.

March 9, 2013
More Editorials Headlines

Editorials

Search Results

High court considers death penalty, intent

AP Analysis

Site Map

Contact Us